SuperPay CR Friction Review
SuperPay · CR friction review ← → to move between slides

Account review · SuperPay · Change requests portfolio

All 47 SuperPay change requests hit at least one delivery pain point.

We reviewed every change request on the SuperPay account against eleven recurring delivery problems. None ran clean. Two patterns stand out: work is pushed to us as urgent, and once delivered it waits on late or invalid UAT before it can close.

47
change requests reviewed
100%
hit at least one pain point
25/47
CRs came in as urgent or falsely urgent
19
CRs with late UAT or invalid / no sign-off
8
CRs cancelled after cost approval
2.6
pain points per CR on average

Pattern 1 · Urgency

Most SuperPay CRs come to us as urgent: 25 of 47.

That is 53% of all CRs, and 18 of the 31 CRs we delivered (58%). Leaving out cancelled CRs, it is 25 of 40 (63%). The urgency is often created upstream, and often does not hold.

Every delivered CR, one square each

016
Mov
014
013
037
Enh
App
Bal
Faw
Faw
WE
017
Cha
023
Cre
STS
P1
P1
P1
Mer
Mer
Mer
Mer
Mer
P1
Age
Off
Non
Vou
Ser
Cas
Flagged urgent or false-urgent
Not flagged
25
CRs flagged urgent or falsely urgent53% of all 47 CRs
8
of those urgent CRs also involved Edafa lateUrgency created by late engagement, not by the work itself
5
CRs flagged as false urgencyPushed as urgent, then the urgency did not hold
6
“urgent” CRs were later parkedRushed to start, then left waiting
7
urgent CRs changed after deliveryDelivered fast to a requirement that then moved

Pattern 2 · UAT and sign-off

Urgent to build, slow to accept: 11 of the 19 CRs with UAT problems were pushed to us as urgent.

19 CRs show very late UAT (14) or an invalid or missing sign-off (7). Delivered work then sits in testing and cannot be invoiced.

9/16
CRs waiting in “Delivered on Testing” have late UAT or no valid sign-off
4/6
delivered CRs with payment due are held by UAT or sign-off
11
CRs urgent at request, then slow or invalid at UAT
15/31
delivered CRs hit very late UAT or an invalid / missing sign-off
1.5 yrs
ET profile parked with UAT outstanding

CRs with late UAT or invalid / no sign-off

Enhancement: Check Transaction Status in Queue
Delivered on Testing · payment: Paid
Urgent requestInvalid / no sign-offFalse urgency
Apply customer number filter in detailed reports
On Production · payment: Due
Urgent requestVery late UAT
Balance Journal Modification | Acceptance Wallets
On Production · payment: Paid
Urgent requestInvalid / no sign-off
023 Resume Sahl Backend Reversal
Deployment in progress · payment: Planned
Urgent requestInvalid / no sign-offFalse urgency
P1 - A2B Enhancement
Delivered on Testing · payment: Planned
Urgent requestVery late UAT
Offline Bill Support and MultiOptions Response Unification
UAT · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestInvalid / no sign-off
ET profile (parked 1.5 years)
Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestVery late UATInvalid / no sign-off
Multiple Accounts for Cash Services
Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestInvalid / no sign-off
Merchant App OTP
Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestVery late UATFalse urgency
Voucher cash out (GLC)
Phase 1 on production · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestVery late UAT
Cash Settlement
On Production · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestVery late UATInvalid / no sign-off
016 Pay by Reference (Super Code)
Delivered on Testing · payment: Due
Very late UAT
014 Offline Bills Module
Delivered on Testing · payment: Paid
Very late UAT
017 Resume – Suspend Service Backend Biller
Delivered on Testing · payment: Planned
Very late UAT
021 Suspend or Resume | Meter (Prepaid Utilities)
Cost Approved · payment: Planned
Very late UAT
Credential reset part 2
Delivered on Testing · payment: Due
Very late UAT
STS Cash wallet withdraw
Delivered on Testing · payment: Due
Very late UAT
P1 - Create batch | Withdraw Transaction Service Ticket #001388
Delivered on Testing · payment: Planned
Very late UAT
Service wizard
Delivered on Testing · payment: Not tracked
Very late UAT

What goes wrong, ranked

Raw business documents and urgent requests lead the list.

Number of CRs affected by each pain point, out of 47. Colour shows the stage of the engagement; urgency and UAT items are marked.

Urgent requestUrgencyCommitment
24 · 51%
Raw BRD, no technical specRequirements
23 · 49%
Very late UATUATAcceptance
14 · 30%
Changed after deliveryAcceptance
12 · 26%
Parked CRCommitment
10 · 21%
Late involvementCommitment
9 · 19%
Cancelled after cost approvalCommitment
8 · 17%
Invalid / no sign-offUATAcceptance
7 · 15%
Ambiguous requirementsRequirements
6 · 13%
Not related to GLERequirements
6 · 13%
False urgencyUrgencyCommitment
5 · 11%

Where it goes wrong

The problems are not isolated. They hit every stage of the CR lifecycle.

25

Requirements quality

CRs affected (of 47). Requests arrive unclear, unspecified, or outside the GLE product scope, so Edafa does the client's analysis work before estimating.

  • Raw BRD, no technical spec23
  • Ambiguous requirements6
  • Not related to GLE6
37

Planning & commitment

CRs affected (of 47). Edafa is brought in late, then work is rushed, parked, or cancelled after the cost was approved.

  • Urgent request24
  • Parked CR10
  • Late involvement9
  • Cancelled after cost approval8
  • False urgency5
21

Acceptance & closure

CRs affected (of 47). Delivered work waits on UAT and sign-off, then the requirement changes after delivery.

  • Very late UAT14
  • Changed after delivery12
  • Invalid / no sign-off7

30 of 47 CRs are affected at two or more stages: a request that starts badly specified is also the one that gets rushed, parked, or changed after delivery.

Representative cases

The worst CRs stack four or five problems on a single request.

Each card is one change request. Chips are the pain points marked against it.

5

016 Pay by Reference (Super Code)

Delivered on Testing · payment: Due
Ambiguous requirementsRaw BRD, no technical specLate involvementVery late UATChanged after delivery
5

Balance Journal Modification | Acceptance Wallets

On Production · payment: Paid
Urgent requestAmbiguous requirementsLate involvementInvalid / no sign-offChanged after delivery
5

021 Suspend or Resume | Meter (Prepaid Utilities)

Cost Approved · payment: Planned
Ambiguous requirementsRaw BRD, no technical specParked CRVery late UATChanged after delivery
5

Merchant App OTP

Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestParked CRVery late UATFalse urgencyCancelled after cost approval
4

Apply customer number filter in detailed reports

On Production · payment: Due
Urgent requestParked CRVery late UATChanged after delivery
4

023 Resume Sahl Backend Reversal

Deployment in progress · payment: Planned
Urgent requestRaw BRD, no technical specInvalid / no sign-offFalse urgency
4

P1 - A2B Enhancement

Delivered on Testing · payment: Planned
Urgent requestAmbiguous requirementsRaw BRD, no technical specVery late UAT
4

Offline Bill Support and MultiOptions Response Unification

UAT · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestLate involvementInvalid / no sign-offChanged after delivery
4

ET profile (parked 1.5 years)

Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Parked for about 18 months with UAT still outstanding.
Urgent requestParked CRVery late UATInvalid / no sign-off
4

Penetration Test

Not tracked · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestNot related to GLERaw BRD, no technical specLate involvement
4

Cash Settlement

On Production · payment: Not tracked
Urgent requestParked CRVery late UATInvalid / no sign-off

Outcome

Only 12 of 47 CRs are live in production, and 8 were cancelled after cost approval.

The friction shows up in the outcome: work waiting on the client side, delivered work not yet paid, and estimation effort spent on CRs that were later dropped.

Delivery status

On Production12
Phase 1 on production1
Delivered on Testing16
UAT1
Deployment in progress1
Cost Approved5
Pending cost approval3
Under review2
Not tracked6

Payment status

Paid11
Due6
Planned10
Cancelled7
Not tracked13

Evidence · every CR × every pain point

Full CR matrix

Tap a stage to filter. Tap a pain point column header to show only the CRs it affects; tap “All pain points” to clear.

Showing 47 of 47 CRs

Change requestStatusPaymentTotal
016 Pay by Reference (Super Code)Delivered on TestingDue5
Move Merchant from Direct to IndirectOn ProductionDue3
014 Offline Bills ModuleDelivered on Testing3
013 Vodafone NBA CROn Production3
037 Elsekka ElhadidOn Production2
Enhancement: Check Transaction Status in QueueDelivered on Testing3
Apply customer number filter in detailed reportsOn ProductionDue4
Balance Journal Modification | Acceptance WalletsOn Production5
Fawry Cancellation Handler + Reprint APIs modificationOn Production1
Fawry reverse | Payment Timeout (Fawry Reconciliation)On Production1
WE QUERY implementation enhancementOn Production3
017 Resume – Suspend Service Backend BillerDelivered on TestingPlanned3
021 Suspend or Resume | Meter (Prepaid Utilities)Cost ApprovedPlanned5
Change User Wallets By Batch ModuleOn Production2
023 Resume Sahl Backend ReversalDeployment in progressPlanned4
Credential reset part 2Delivered on TestingDue2
STS Cash wallet withdrawDelivered on TestingDue2
P1 - New service | Penalty Ticket #001387On Production2
P1 - A2B EnhancementDelivered on TestingPlanned4
P1 - On credit Balance extra requirementsDelivered on TestingPlanned1
Merchant App PD Phase 1 – Delivered ChangesDelivered on TestingDue3
Merchant App PD Phase 1 – Suspension per Device TypeDelivered on TestingPlanned2
Merchant App PD Phase 1 – Mobile Type Indication in GLEDelivered on TestingPlanned2
Merchant App PD Phase 2 – Suspension Reason Not Captured per TerminalDelivered on TestingPlanned2
Merchant App PD Phase 2 – Resend OTP ButtonDelivered on TestingPlanned2
Low Balance Trigger (POS PD) – Portal Alerts ManagementPending cost approvalCancelled2
Low Balance Trigger (POS PD) – Backend ModificationsPending cost approvalCancelled2
Low Balance Trigger (POS PD) / Product Revamp – Recharge Message to AgentPending cost approvalCancelled2
Pattern Validation – Mobile Scenario Configuration PageCost ApprovedCancelled2
Pattern Validation – Add Pattern per Input/Service PageCost ApprovedCancelled2
Pattern Validation – Batch ProcessCost ApprovedCancelled2
P3 - Product Revamp - Get Ambiguous Transaction StatusCost ApprovedCancelled1
P1 - Create batch | Withdraw Transaction Service Ticket #001388Delivered on TestingPlanned1
Agent Banking CR (STS Transaction Enquiry and Reversal)Delivered on Testing2
Offline Bill Support and MultiOptions Response UnificationUATNot tracked4
ET profile (parked 1.5 years)Not trackedNot tracked4
Penetration TestNot trackedNot tracked4
Multiple Accounts for Cash ServicesNot trackedNot tracked3
Adding category to receiptNot trackedNot tracked2
CVMUnder reviewNot tracked2
Extra APIs GLCUnder reviewNot tracked2
Merchant App OTPNot trackedNot tracked5
Merchant App LinkingNot trackedNot tracked3
Non-POS merchant OTP linkingOn ProductionNot tracked1
Voucher cash out (GLC)Phase 1 on productionNot tracked3
Service wizardDelivered on TestingNot tracked2
Cash SettlementOn ProductionNot tracked4
Total CRs affected2466239101475128124

Source: SuperPay CR payment tracking workbook, sheet “list_with_pain_points”, marked by Edafa FinTech Delivery. CRs at the bottom of the list have no delivery or payment status recorded in the source and show as “Not tracked”.